The Tallest Tree in the Forest, actor and playwright Daniel Beaty’s new one-man show about the life of African American actor, singer, and activist Paul Robeson, ends with Beaty eulogizing Robeson with some of Robeson’s own words: “The artist must take sides. He must elect to fight for freedom or slavery. I have made my choice.” That quote, which would become Robeson’s epitaph, provides an accurate summation of Beaty’s view of Robeson, an artist and performer whose real-life dedication to human rights causes and early support of the Soviet Union saw him branded as a Communist by the press and government of the United States and driven out of show business almost until the end of his life.
Before he came under fire from J. Edgar Hoover and Senator Joseph McCarthy, Robeson spent a number of years building a massive following as an international film and theatre star. He is probably best remembered for his role as Joe in Hammerstein and Kern’s groundbreaking musical Show Boat—specifically, for his rendition of the show’s most famous song, "Ol' Man River"—but Robeson was actually not the first actor to play the role. (He took over from the original Joe, Jules Bledsoe, when the show opened in London in 1928, and subsequently played the role twice more on stage, as well as in the 1936 filmed musical.) So great was his popularity that the lawyer-turned-performer even sang before the Prince of Wales.
Beaty depicts Robeson as a man constantly at odds with the circumstances of his life: at first in love with performing, but under pressure from his late father to choose a “respectable” career in the law; ambivalent about the opportunities for African American actors, but hen-pecked by his wife and manager, Essie, into taking roles about which he holds reservations; fiercely attached to his familial and cultural history in the United States, but somewhat despairing of the possibilities for positive social change in the country where he was born. Scholars of contemporary African American theatre and dramatic history, in particular, could find much in this play (in performance at the Kansas City Repertory Theatre through September 28, 2013) to focus on.
As an act of scholarly recovery, one might compare The Tallest Tree in the Forest to Alice Walker’s “In Search of Zora Neale Hurston.” Just as Walker’s 1975 article for Ms. Magazine helped bring Hurston and her work back to their rightful place in the body of African American literature, so does Beaty’s play—which takes its name from the title that educator and civil rights Mary McLeod Bethune once bestowed on Robeson—seek to help restore Robeson to his rightful position as an important contributor to African American theatrical history and to the cause of civil rights.